Asus ROG Xbox Ally X review

The best gaming handheld and rival to the Steam Deck, but it’s far from perfect

Intro

The Asus ROG Xbox Ally X is Microsoft’s big attempt to really show that Windows is a great platform for a gaming handheld and that it might finally be time to upgrade from your Steam Deck to a more powerful gaming handheld.

And, in terms of hardware, it’s an attempt that largely succeeds, but in terms of software, all the same old problems with trying to use Windows without a keyboard and mouse are still here.

Buy the Asus ROG Xbox Ally X via these links, and you’ll be helping to support this website. Amazon US: https://amzn.to/44ZQ3JS Amazon UK: https://amzn.to/4fKwMku

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Huge upgrade in gaming performance over Steam Deck and original ROG Ally
  • New Xbox Windows mode boosts performance
  • Comfortable grip design
  • Impressive battery life

Cons

  • Grips make for less portable device
  • Windows still pales in comparison to SteamOS for overall usability
  • Very expensive

Features and Xbox interface

Externally, then, the Xbox Ally X is basically just an ROG Ally X but with a new grip design. That means you get the same microSD slot, headphone jack and two USB-C ports on the top edge, the same 7-inch, 1080p LCD display on the front, the same speakers, the same slightly too bright RGB rings around the thumbsticks, and the same face buttons.

All, that is, except for the addition of a new Xbox button. This brings up an overlay in the top left of the screen that provides quick access to your recent games, your Xbox profile, key device settings like changing the power mode of the device, and of course there’s a CoPilot AI too.

The other big Xbox addition is a new launcher. This loads when the device boots up and features a home page that has your recently launched games, other featured games, deals and more. There’s also a Game Pass tab, a library tab, Cloud gaming tab, a store tab, and a tab for your Xbox profile. The home and library tabs will show games from other launchers, such as Steam and Epic, and the whole thing is supposed to act as the hub of the device.

However, both the overlay and the Xbox app have some serious issues. For a start, following a recent firmware update, hitting the Xbox button on my device now launches Steam Big Picture as well as the overlay, causing the overlay to no longer respond to dpad inputs. It’s also confusing that the actual device settings are pushed off into the Asus ROG command center section. It feels very far from a slick console-like experience.

Likewise, the Xbox app is hopeless. The Home page just shows icons of your games, without showing the name of the game until you select it. Sure, you probably know which is which, but should you really be made to guess. Hit the Game Pass section and it doesn’t show the games you actual have on Game Pass already installed but just has a load of ads for other games. Indeed, every other feature of the interface just feels like its shoving adverts down your throat. All the while, it doesn’t include any actual settings for your device in this interface so it doesn’t feel like it’s a one stop shop for managing your experience, like it does on the Steam Deck.

So, the Xbox stuff here is all but entirely a waste of time, but thankfully there are many other reasons to like this device.

Screen and grips

For a start, while the controller grips on the sides look, kind of ridiculous, and add a bit of extra bulk, they do actually work well. They’re easily the most comfortable handheld grips I’ve used, and they make it easy to wield one handed.

The fact that the core controls and connections are just like that of the Ally X also means you have a setup that just works. It’s not fancy or packed with extra features, but it feels comfortable and easy to use.

The screen is also decent. It has great viewing angles for an LCD, reasonably punchy colors, and its inclusion of variable refresh rate and Freesync means it always looks smooth and free of tearing and stutter even when you’re just running at 30Hz. However, there’s no denying that an OLED would be even nicer. The black levels and contrast here are just that of a standard IPS LCD and the color range is strictly non-HDR as well. That’s realistically fine for gaming but the fact you can’t watch dazzling, high contrast, high saturation HDR video on a $1000 handheld is a bit disappointing.

Performance

Then we get to the real heart of the matter, which is this device’s inclusion of the AMD Ryzen Z2 Extreme. There are sevearl other devices now available or hitting the market very soon that have the same Radeon 890M GPU of this chip, but this is the first device of this calibre that I’ve used, and the step up from the likes of the Steam Deck and ROG Ally X is big.

Using the device’s default 17W mode, in Cyberpunk 2077 it can hit 40fps average running at 1080p with medium detail settings and using FSR balanced. Plug the device in and crank up to 35W mode and that rises to 49fps average, and the game looks great.

You can even game with ray tracing. In the low ray tracing preset at 1080p with FSR balanced you can hit 29fps. It’s only just playable, but it’s still impressive.

Meanwhile, in Indiana Jones and the Great Circle, a game which forces on ray tracing, you can hit 46fps average in 35W mode and, again, it looks great. Switch to 17W mode and you’re still getting 39fps average, which is still plenty playable on a device like this.

Battery life

Battery life is excellent too. The 80Wh unit lasted just under two hours in the quite demanding PCMark 10 gaming battery life test, with the device running in its maximum 25W battery mode and running without the FPS limiter helping to reduce the workload on the GPU. But, this immediately jumps to three hours in 17W mode and you’ll get more than double this when playing less demanding games.

Verdict

This all adds up to meaning the Asus ROG Xbox Ally X isn’t some step change for Windows gaming handhelds. It still has nearly all the oddities of trying to navigate Windows with dpad inputs and a touchscreen, and really just goes to show more than ever how Microsoft needs to stop trying to do both things at once and make a proper, complete, dedicated touchscreen style interface for navigating Windows.

Steam already does it well, and I’m not even talking about on the Steam Deck. Big Picture mode on Windows is already fantastic. Microsoft just needs to create a similar launcher that taps into far more of the operating system. But, I digress.

Instead, the main takeaway here is that the Xbox Ally X isn’t a revolution but it is still a great gaming handheld. It’s comfortable to use, the screen is decent, it sounds great, has excellent performance, solid battery life, and crucially, it’s by far the most affordable and readily

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *