Glass mouse pads are back, and here’s why you should care

Cracking mouse mats

As someone that’s been an avid PC gamer for over 30 years, I’ve seen just about every trend come and go, when it comes to gaming mice. From rubber ball mice used on plain desktops through early optical mice and the first generation of cloth mouse pads, laser mice and those hard plastic mouse pads, that whole era of mice having weights added to them for some reason, to today where we have ultra lightweight, wireless mice used on cloth mouse pads that often cover most of your desk. For someone that had been through all those stages, it has definitely felt for a while now that we have essentially hit the peak of mousing for gaming PCs.

So imagine my surprise when I saw that there was a growing enthusiasm over the last few years, for using glass mouse pads. You see, I remember the first generation of glass mouse pads when they arrived 25 years ago. They were cold, rough feeling, noisy, and would destroy the feet of your mouse about as fast as playing on a piece of sandpaper. They were, in short, not very good.

But, I suppose there’s a chance things have moved on in the last 25 years, so I figured I had to give the new generation a chance. So, to that end, I’ve grabbed myself three of these new glass mouse pads to try over the next few weeks to see if there’s really any merit to them and whether I’d recommend anyone else make the switch. For testing, Corsair sent me its MM Glass in its large size, Razer sent me its new ultra thin Atlas Pro, and I grabbed myself one of the hugely popular Wallhack SP-004 pads. Wallhack has a newer SP-005 pad that’s a bit thinner and has a chamfered edge, but by all accounts, the surface is the same, so I should be able to get a decent feel for what Wallhack offers with this one.

So, immediately upon unboxing these mouse mats, the single most obvious thing about them is that they’re massive. For years I’ve been using XXL or full desk cloth pads, so I effectively don’t need to worry about fitting the mouse pad on my desk along side my keyboard and other gear, because everything on my desk just goes on the mouse pad. So, switching back to having to make space for such an enormous mouse mat immediately got these all off to a bad start.

Beyond that, comparing these three pads, the thinness of the Razer Atlas Pro immediately stands out. The glass is just 1.1mm thick, and the whole pad is just 1.9mm thick. This compares to 2mm of glass and 3mm total thickness for the Corsair MM Glass and xxxmm of glass and 3.9mm of total thickness for the Wallhack SP-004. The SP-005 is thinner at just 2.9mm total, but the Razer is still well ahead of the pack on this front.

This is of course comes with pros and cons. Even with a full rubber backing supporting the whole pad, any sharp knock when you happen to be carrying this thing, well, I can only assume it’s going to fare worse than these thicker mats. As with all these pads, you’ll also need to make sure you’re using this on a totally flat surface. Any slight wobbles in your desk surface and the pad will wobble distractingly but more importantly any force that might make the pad to flex could cause it to crack.

Otherwise, that thinness is lovely. It just sits so much more flush with your desk and there’s less of a feeling of a harsh edge when you knock against it. Ideally mouse pads wouldn’t add any extra height or encumbrance to your desk, and the thinner the pad, the closer you are to that ideal.

As for other first impressions, well, unsurprisingly, they are cold, and rough. Back in the day when I used that first generation of glass mouse mats, I just coped with this fact, but these days, I’d definitely recommend grabbing a gaming sleeve to be able to use these comfortably. They’ll take the edge off the cold and provide a smoother glide that doesn’t wear away the side of your hand. These sleeves are quite useful anyway, as they can help wick away sweat as well as keeping your hands a bit warmer in winter. Along with the mouse pads, I’ll provide a link to the one I use in the description.

Another immediately obvious thing is the noise of these pads. A hard, rough glass surface with a hard plastic mouse skating across its surface creates quite the din that is distracting if you’re gaming with speakers or open back headphones, and will annoy the hell out of anyone nearby. It’s nowhere near as bad as those early glass pads, as they just had single rubber feet in each corner, so the glass could vibrate and ring out like a bell. The full rubber backing of these pads, mostly deadens that affect, but these are still noisy. Here’s a comparison to some cloth pads.

So, that’s quite a few downsides noted already, but the final thing you notice straight away with these pads is their big upside, which is speed. This is the main reason why these pads have become popular again, and it’s as clear as day. The extent to which your mouse just effortlessly glides across these even compared to the fastest speed cloth pads is striking.

Whether that speed is super necessary or something I actually like at all is something I’ll be testing over the coming weeks, but the difference is clear.

So that’s it for my first impressions, I’ll report back in a few seconds as to how I actually found using these…

Oh, ok, I get it now.

So, what’s the big deal here? Well, what it all comes down to is not actually outright speed, as I suggested earlier, but rather it’s the ease of consistent sliding. As my tests just showed, these pads aren’t necessarily much faster than some soft pads just when testing just the weight of a mouse sliding on their surface. But, once you account for other factors, they feel faster and smoother.

Those factors include things like the weight of your hand pushing down on the mouse, which pushes it slightly into the surface of a soft mouse pad, making it feel like it’s more effort to get the mouse moving. The motion you make when moving a mouse also has a slight amount of downward force to – particularly if you tend to get more aggressive with your movements on occasion – and this can again cause your mouse to dig into the surface of a soft mat. With these glass pads, though, that digging in effect just can’t happen. As soon as you’ve overcome the slight initial friction of the pad’s surface your mouse just goes. There’s a reason the first ever glass mouse pad was called the icemat, as the sensation really is like your feet sliding out from under you when walking on ice.

Now, crucially, this effect comes with upsides but has some downsides too. The main positive is that it just feels so effortless to perform fast movements in general, and particularly to do quick changes in direction. When tracking fast moving opponents or performing speedy movements it just feels so easy with these pads. As a result, they feel fantastic for games like Apex Legends, Overwatch, or Quake where so much of the game is about the flow of your movement, quick turns and tracking based aiming. The style of weapons also helps too. Fully automatic guns with reasonably controllable recoil or even hit scan weapons are perfect for the movement you get with these mouse pads.

On the flip side, if you’re playing games where short, fast, precise single shots are more important, the lack of stopping power in these mats is their main downside. This slipperiness can make your aim feel imprecise and jittery sometimes, especially for things like sniping where you want to be able to rely on your mouse staying exactly on the spot you’ve chosen when you press down on that left mouse button. On these glass pads, it can sometimes feel like even the tiny movement of pressing a button can throw off your aim.

And this is exactly why control style mouse pads exist. These are soft style pads that actively have a slower feeling top surface than normal soft pads, which is supposed to make them ideal for making your mouse feel planted and being able to stop on a dime, meaning you don’t have to overcorrect because your arm momentum has sent your mouse flying past the point you were aiming for.

For games such as Counter-Strike, Rainbow six Siege and Valorant that’s where these style of pads are often preferred.

Now, none of this is new. Those 20 year old glass pads provided essentially the same feeling. However, a key difference these days is the lightness of a lot of current mice. With mice that weighed 100g to 150g the inertia of flinging those mice around meant that when using a slippery hard mouse mat you were really fighting the inertia of that mouse. With the likes of Corsair’s new Sabre V3 Pro that weighs just 41g, it’s significantly easier to stop dead.

As such, I still very much enjoyed using this mouse for games like Counter-Strike, even if I wouldn’t necessarily pick it over a control style mat.

So that’s the core performance of these mats, but there are other reasons why I was somewhat won over by them.

For a start the surface of these new style of glass pads I think feels smoother than the old style, though don’t hold me to that, as it’s possible I’m slightly misremembering. Nonetheless, from memory they used to have a scratchier feeling surface that wasn’t pleasant on your hands and very rapidly wore away the feet of your mice.

Here, though, it’s almost like top of each bump in the etched the surface has been smoothed over, making it feel even faster and less like it’s grinding away the bottom of your mouse. These pads will still wear away the feet of your mouse quicker than a soft pad, but not as quick as before. Plus, this is another advantage of changing times, as modern mice often either come with a spare set of feet or replacements are readily available. That wasn’t the case 20 years ago.

Another factor that’s much improved is noise. While these are still a little bit noisier than soft mouse pads, they’re nowhere near as noisy as the old ones. The full rubber backing completely deadens any sounds so while you do get a little bit of that initial woosh of the mouse on the surface, the sound doesn’t reverb or ring out.

Other things I like are that these are super easy to clean. Soft pads are easy enough to give a scrub in the bath, but they often don’t actually come out looking as good as new. Here, though, well this Wallhack SP-004 was already secondhand when I bought it and it’s completely spotless. You do have to be careful about putting hard materials on it that could scratch it, such as placing the unglazed base of a mug on on it, but otherwise it’s super resilient and just wipes clean.

So that’s a lot of good things, but there are some more downsides. For a start, they’re just too big. I know a lot of gamers want huge mouse mats so they can use low mouse sensitivity, but particularly the height of several of these seems excessive and almost like it’s a bit of an arms race where companies have cottoned on to the idea that gamers want large mouse pads so each generation grows in size just so they can claim to be offering more.

Regardless, the crucial point is that most of these are only available in one size. Large soft mouse pads exist but so do smaller ones or full desk pads. With these though, it’s find enough space or you’re out of luck.

Also, they’re cold. I already mentioned about wearing a gaming sleeve, but in colder months like right now here in the UK, you may even want a full fingerless glove like this one because the surface of these just sucks the heat out of your hand. At least, that’s the case for the Wallhack and the Corsair pads. However, the much thinner glass of the Razer Atlas Pro seems to warm up much quicker so that if your hand is resting in mostly the same position, it doesn’t take long for that area to feel like it’s much less cold to the touch.

All of which brings me to the differences between these three pads, and there are more than you might think. Continuing with the Razer Atlas Pro, its thinness really is big advantage – it’s not just a gimmick. It sits on your desk in a more unobtrusive way, it doesn’t feel as cold, it isn’t as likely to interfere with the armrest of your chair as much, and it doesn’t raise your right arm up so much realtive to your left arm. However, as noted before, it will need a particularly flat surface to sit on, as it won’t otherwise stay completely flat.

The super minimalist look of this black pad on a black desk also looks fantastic.

As for its surface finish, it sits somewhere between the more textured and faster feel of the Wallhack and the finer grained and slightly slower feel of the Corsair.

Speaking of that feel, the Corsair has a distinctly differnet surface feel to the other two. It’s that much smoother but to the point where it can almost feel like it clings to your mouse and skin slightly more than the rougher texture of the other two pads, a bit like how your finger will stick to the surface of perfectly smooth clear glass. For this reason, it was actually my least favorite of the three in terms of that smoothness of movement that you want from a glass pad. It’s still good and the pad looks great, but on balance I slightly preferred the other two.

On which, the Wallhack SP-004 is my favorite for surface feel. It has what initially feels like the roughest or bumpiest texture, but most has that rounded over smoothness to the bumps which I was talking about early. This makes it feel ultra fast and slightly less like it’s chewing through your mouse feet.

However, this pad is the thickest and tallest, so I preferred it least to simply have on my desk. The new, thinner SP-005 with its chamfered edge solve the thickness problem but it retains the same 44 x 51cm size, compared to the 40 x 50cm size of the other two.

So, will am I a glass mouse pad convert? In truth, probably not. I simply don’t play enough competitive FPS these days to put up with the downsides, so will instead be going back to my full desk pad. However, I will keep one of these on hand for my occasional Apex sessions.

But what about you? Are you a died in the wool glass pad user now or are you the complete opposite and prefer a control style mouse pad? Or, maybe you have both and switch between them depending on the game you’re playing. Either way, let me know your thoughts in the comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *