Steam Machine review

The Steam Machine price is the least of its problems

Intro

When the Steam Machine price was finally revealed, most people were rightly disappointed. What seemed like it might be not only an easy to use console-like gaming PC for the living room with a console-like price to match, had suddenly landed at price that was basically double what most of us were hoping to pay.

And, in many ways, that is the whole story. It’s just too expensive for what it offers. However, there’s actually more going on here than simply a price that’s too high. In fact, within reason, I think it almost wouldn’t have mattered how low Valve made the Steam Machine price, as it was always going to be far more of a niche product than most of us ever realised.

The reasons for that are several but, first, let’s establish what Valve mostly did get right.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Fantastically small and cute design
  • Runs very cool and quiet
  • Quick and easy to setup
  • Powers on via controller
  • Has HDMI CEC support
  • Much more powerful than Steam Deck

Cons

  • Worse performance than Xbox X and PS5
  • Can’t play games with anti-cheat
  • 4K performance is highly variable
  • Overall performance lags well behind equivalent-price PC
  • Simply too expensive

Design

For a start there’s its design. It’s only when actually handling it that you fully appreciate just how impressively small and compact the Steam Machine truly is, and there’s just something joyous about that. An entire gaming PC that you can, just about, fit in the palm of your hand is undeniably cool.

Funnily enough, though, this does bring us to the first not downside, but a slightly needless aspect of this device. And that’s that having a really small, neat looking PC actually feels like it matters more for those wanting a minimalist desk setup, rather than for those caring about whether a gaming PC in the living room will look out of place.

After all, the PS5 is massive, and the Xbox Series X is almost exactly twice the size of the Steam Machine. When you also factor in that most TV cabinets are optimised for much wider and often slimmer devices than this, having such a tiny cube seems a bit pointless.

Still, it’s great that the front plate is swappable, as it adds a nice way to customize the Steam Machine without otherwise tampering with any of the rest of it, potentially harming its warranty or resale value.

Again, though, there’s a but. You see, Valve’s included alternative front plates don’t, to me, look very good. The walnut wood one is too dark to provide a nice contrast with the black, while the sort of felt textured orange plate just looks, well, a bit odd.

Maybe, if you’ve got the Machine mounted in a TV cabinet where you can only really see the front plate, it works better, but where you can see the whole cube, the alternative covers just seem like they’re a bit out of place, breaking up the seamless lines of the black cube.

Experimenting with them a bit, I think I prefer the wooden cover placed over the black plate, so there’s an overhang. It just seems to set off the design better, but maybe that’s just me.

Thermals

One really impressive aspect of the Steam Machine, though, is how cool and quiet it runs. Its single 120mm fan is effectively silent when idling and the device only ramps up to around 35dB when under load. That’s a level you simply won’t be able to hear when you’re sat on your sofa and playing on a TV, and it’s hardly noticeable even when the Steam Machine is next to your on a desk.

The CPU and GPU also tick along at a decently cool CPU 70°C and 75°C respectively, when under load.

Ports and ease of setup

Other factors such as connectivity are entirely adequate here, too, with the one HDMI and one DisplayPort being all you should ever need for video connections, and you’ve got plenty of USBs front and back, wired Ethernet, and decently fast WiFi.

Also, the use of an internal power supply that further adds to just how impressive it is that this device is so small. It also means you really can use this as a portable device. Just the machine, a controller and a power cable are often all you need to take with you, as many TV setups will have a device from which you can borrow an HDMI cable.

Here, though, we bump up against, again, not another downside, but a feature that just doesn’t actually matter that much, and that’s ability to have the Steam Machine power on just by pressing the Steam button on a Steam Controller. It’s definitely cool, and a nice to have, but it would be even cooler on a larger, more powerful gaming PC that you really care about having hidden away in the corner of a room, not on a device that’s so small and effectively designed to be put on show, where you can just walk up to it and press the power button.

Now, again, it’s not a complaint, but if you’re talking about whether it’s worth spending more money on a device like this for that feature, for me personally, I’d much rather that budget went on more powerful hardware inside.

Likewise, the HDMI CEC feature that allows the Machine to easily communicate with your TV, soundbar, and other AV gear. It’s cool, but it doesn’t actually feel that impactful. It’s a console convenience in a device that in so many ways still doesn’t really feel like a true plug and play console experience.

Gaming performance benchmarks

All of which brings us to the real elephant in the cube, here, which is performance. I won’t labour the point too much, as I’m sure most of you know about the modest performance of the Steam Machine already, but if you’re in any doubt, it really is underwhelming.

When it launched six months after it was announced, Valve almost immediately pulled back on its original claim of the Steam Machine providing 60fps 4K performance, and rightly so. Up to 4K gaming is now the claim, and that’s a fair summation, but even then it’s often with some heavy compromises.

For a start, the device defaults to running games at 1080p anyway, so you have to go into the settings to change this.

Then, once done so, any games with ray tracing are basically a non starter. It’ll run games like Indiana Jones and the Great Circle and Doom the Dark Ages, but you’ll often have to use FSR upscaling set to Performance, so the game is only actually rendering at 1080p, and even then you’ll still have to use just medium detail settings.

The experience is playable, and if actually like me, you still happen to have an old 1080p TV, it can be a decent experience, but it doesn’t look amazing, and you’re still often playing at under 60fps in this class of game.

Meanwhile, for non ray traced modern games, like Forza Horizon 6 or Cyberpunk 2077, you can play at 4K, but you’ll likely be looking at closer to 30fps using medium to high detail settings, with upscaling required to push above that. Again that’s not an awful experience, but it’s not great.

Crucially, using upscaling to hit 4K was far from reliable, with it simply not available or working in some games, and sometimes not meaningfully improving performance.

Moreover, there’s just generally quite a bit of messing around to get games running well, particularly as a lot of default settings in games are really low. Forza Horizon 6 looked like at 20 year old game on its default low settings, but yet the game can actually run okay at much higher settings.

So, in other words, the Steam Machine will play the latest games, but not in a way that’s particularly visually compelling, and not without some hassle. And if you’re trying to compete with the latest consoles or established gaming PCs, that’s not a particularly convincing experience.

Meanwhile, at the other end of the spectrum, the Steam Machine will of course play the vast array of older, retro, 2D, and generally less demanding games that are available on Steam. But, here’s the crucial bit, so can any cheap PC and, perhaps more importantly, so will the Steam Deck. And that device you can then just pick up and play with anywhere.

Of course, the Steam Deck has had its own massive price rise, so it’s no longer fair to think of it as a $500 alternative, but if you’ve already got one, the Steam Machine isn’t bringing much else to the table.

That’s especially true when you consider that many competitive games like Apex Legends and Fortnite won’t work on the Steam Machine, thanks to their anticheat systems not being compatible with SteamOS.

Upgradability

The final aspect that any existing PC gamer will likely find an issue, is the lack of upgradability of this device. Its CPU and GPU are soldered in place and it relies on pricey laptop memory. Its SSD is upgradable, and the Machine has a microSD slot, but microSD cards are slow, and the SSD will need to have its data transferred to a larger drive manually using another PC.

Verdict

So, in summary, the Steam machine does fit the specific niche of PC gamers who have an existing Steam library who don’t already own a living room gaming PC and probably don’t already own a Steam Deck or other gaming handheld and who want to play TV and controller friendly games that aren’t too demanding but which are demanding enough that they won’t run well enough on the Steam Deck, and which don’t have anti cheat. And, while that market does exist, it’s actually a pretty small one.

Sure, if Valve had managed to drop the Steam Machine at its hoped-for price of around $500, or less, then it would’ve been so cheap that, even with all the above caveats, it would’ve been a great value buy. Who wouldn’t want a convenient living room gaming PC that costs less than you’d be able to build one for yourself?

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *